Taylor Metcalfe earned all American honors while playing on the Rollins College golf team that finished first, second, third and fourth in the NCAA Division II National championship during his four years there. He ended his college career in style, with a hole in one on his last shot in his final NCAA tournament, one of nine career aces!
Over the years, Taylor has amassed a competitive record that a few amateurs can match. Among the many highlights:
- Winner of the 1970 and 1982 Cincinnati Metro Championships
- Runner up to Jay Sigel in Pine Valley Golf Club's Crump Cup in 1975
- Winner of the 1976 Ohio Amateur at Springfield CC
- Qualified for eight U.S. Amateurs- took Bill Kratzert to extra holes 1973 and the same with eventual champion Jay Sigel in 1983
- Qualified for two U.S. MidAm and two U.S. Senior AM championships
- Winner with partner of two Tri-State (Ohio, Indiana and Kentucky) championships
- Winner of two Tournament of Champions and one Tournament of Champion, Senior Division
- Winner of twenty five club championships (Wyoming GC-21, Belfair GC -2, Webhannet Club -1, Heritage Club -1)
- Winner with Denny Gallagher of the Charlie Coe Invitational at Castle Pines Golf Club
- Winner of consecutive Ohio Senior Hall of Fame Champpionships 2005-2006
- Runner-up in OGA Senior Amateur Championship 2006
- Winner of the 2006 Cincinnati Metro Senior Championship
In addition to his extensive playing accomplishments, Taylor has served on the Board of Directors of Wyoming GC and Heritage Club. Taylor is also a member of the Rollins College Athletic Hall of Fame, the Legends of Golf Cincinnati in 2011 and the Hmailton County Sports Hall of Fame in 2006
